The intersection of Black Street & Chislett Street was controlled by a traffic signal until April 29, 2025, when the signal was damaged in a storm and since that time it has been operating with a temporary all-way stop control.

In Fall 2025, the Department of Mobility and Infrastructure intends to remove the traffic signal from the intersection of Black Street & Chislett Street and replace it with a permanent all-way stop condition. The City has already been receiving comments to this change via 311, however, we are now opening up a 30-day comment period for public comment.

It has long been assumed that traffic signals provide the best results for multi-modal traffic flow at an intersection.

However, the improper use of a signal, especially on low-volume local roads, can negatively impact the intersection.

Some drawbacks include:

• Excessive delay to all users
• Increased noncompliance with the signal (running red lights, etc.)
• Increased collisions

The assumption that traffic signals are the most effective form of traffic control has led to many signals being installed at locations where they are not warranted.

In fact, their presence may have adversely affected the safety and efficiency of vehicular, bicycle, and pedestrian traffic.

The intersection of Black Street and Chislett Street, located in Pittsburgh’s East Liberty neighborhood, was previously identified by DOMI as a potential location for conversion from signal control to all-way stop control. A traffic signal removal study was completed to determine if the traffic signal is still warranted at this location. This traffic study followed methodology described in the Federal Highway’s FHWA-IP-80-12 User Guide for Removal of Not Needed Traffic Signals, which provides guidance and criteria to use while evaluating traffic signals for removal. The study evaluated vehicle volumes, crash data, signal warrants, and operational performance and determined that a traffic signal is not warranted at this intersection. Based the results of the traffic signal removal study, DOMI recommended the traffic signal be removed and replaced permanently with all-way stop control.